The Voluntary Carbon Market (VCM)
Trading in voluntary carbon markets
The Voluntary Carbon Market (VCM) is a market for carbon credits that support corporate efforts to reduce carbon emissions. It provides an asset class for investors and a steady supply of carbon credits. The VCM is growing in size, and by 2021 is expected to double in size. Yet, there are concerns about VCM’s sustainability and the risks it poses.
Voluntary participation in carbon markets is encouraged by philanthropic motivations, a sense of social responsibility, and the perception of a private value or risk. While non-profit organizations are making significant contributions to conservation and environmental protection through the purchase of land and other resources, for-profit companies are increasingly taking part in the market. However, without governmental regulation, participation may decline. While philanthropy is an important component of the voluntary carbon market, it may not be sufficient to keep up with increasing environmental issues.
Regulations
The Paris Rulebook outlines the procedural and substantive requirements for the transfer and trading of carbon credits. These requirements are designed to ensure the integrity of the credits. One such requirement requires that the credits that are generated by a project be valid for a set period of time. During that time, the credit can only be counted once. It is possible for a country to use a carbon credit for other purposes or allow another country to use it, but this must be approved by the host country.
Another important feature of the new carbon rules is their potential to reduce fragmentation and improve integrity in the global carbon market. However, the implementation of these new regulations is still far from certain. Some national regulators are still determining how to implement these rules, and private credit certifying bodies are strengthening their standards in light of the new rules.
Costs
Carbon credits are traded privately and over-the-counter in a market called the carbon credit market. However, some exchanges have recently appeared in order to facilitate the trading of these carbon credits. In addition to facilitating trades, these exchanges will also help the project developers in securing financing for their projects.
The costs of carbon credits vary depending on the type of project. They can range from a few cents per metric ton of CO2 emissions to $15/mtCO2e for projects that involve afforestation. Other credits may be more expensive, for example, those generated by high-tech projects like CCS.
Reliability
There is a great deal of uncertainty about the reliability of trade carbon credits. This is due in large part to the fact that many of these credits are created under outdated schemes. Furthermore, the environmental impact of many of these credits is questionable. Traders might also be tempted to trade old credits, which could have a negative impact on carbon prices and hobble the nascent market. In fact, one study found that as many as 700 million carbon equivalent tons of “old” credits could flood the market, with little or no climate impact.
The voluntary carbon market currently lacks the liquidity required for efficient trading. In addition, the market for carbon credits is highly heterogeneous. The attributes of each credit affect its value, which makes it difficult to match buyers to suppliers. As a result, the process of matching buyers to suppliers is time consuming and inefficient.
Price
In recent years, the price of trade carbon credits has increased significantly. This increase is largely due to the growing interest in carbon credits and the growing ambition of corporations to achieve net-zero emissions. However, the prices of carbon credits fluctuate greatly and are not based on a fixed formula. The price of credits is determined by a number of factors including the volume of carbon credits being traded and the geography of the project. Generally, carbon credits from projects meeting the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are worth more than those from other projects.
Companies are given a certain number of allowances when they first start up. However, if they need more credits in the future, they can trade them for other ones in the market. These credits can be bought and sold like stocks and are controlled by governments.
0
